Which metrics should you track for your Google reviews?
The point of these metrics is not pretty charts: each one comes with a concrete action. A slowing review pace is fixed by asking for more reviews; a low reply rate is fixed by replying; a recurring complaint is fixed on the shop floor, in the kitchen or on the phone.
The 7 metrics, and what they tell you
| Metric | How to read it | The action that goes with it |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Average rating | What customers see; it moves slowly once you have many reviews | Also check the rating of the last 3 months |
| 2. New reviews per month | Your pace; a profile with no recent reviews looks less trustworthy | Ask every happy customer for a review |
| 3. Star split | How many 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1-star reviews; 3-star ones often point to something to fix | Read the 3-star reviews first |
| 4. Reply rate | The share of reviews with a reply | Aim for 100%, at least on recent reviews |
| 5. Unanswered reviews | Your backlog; the easiest number to bring down | Bring it back to zero every week |
| 6. Reply time | The time between the review and your reply | Negative the same day or the next, positive within the week |
| 7. Recurring topics | Words mentioned again and again: waiting, welcome, cleanliness, price, a product, a staff member | Fix it on the ground, then say so in your replies |
For reply times, the guide how fast to reply to Google reviews gives targets by type of review. For a precise definition of reply rate, see the glossary.
Free tool, no sign-up
Google review calculator
How many 5-star reviews to reach your target rating? Enter your rating and number of reviews.
Why your average rating is not enough
Once you have many reviews, each new one barely moves the average: it takes a lot of 5-star reviews to lift a rating by a tenth. That is simple maths, and it is why a stable average can hide a recent slide, or real progress.
Two habits correct for this:
- work out the rating of the last three months’ reviews, next to your overall rating;
- note how many 5-star reviews you would need to reach your goal (4.5 or 4.7, for example).
The Google review calculator does that sum from your current rating and number of reviews.
Spotting the topics that keep coming up
Once a month, read the month’s reviews and note the topics mentioned, good and bad. A simple grid does the job:
| Topic | Mentioned positively | Mentioned negatively | Action decided |
|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome | … | … | … |
| Waiting time | … | … | … |
| Price, value for money | … | … | … |
| Signature product, dish or service | … | … | … |
| Cleanliness, comfort | … | … | … |
When a negative topic keeps coming back, fix it on the ground first, then mention it in your replies (“we now have an extra person on the floor on Saturdays”). Readers can see you listen, and that is often what sets you apart from a competitor who never replies.
Comparing yourself with competitors on Google Maps
Customers do not read your profile on its own: they compare it with the three or four others shown next to it on Google Maps. Each month, note the rating and number of reviews of 3 to 5 direct competitors. The goal is not the best rating in the neighbourhood but not falling behind: a competitor who gets far more reviews than you ends up looking more reliable.
The guide local competitor analysis on Google Maps explains the method, and Voxtya’s Visibility & insights service takes that reading every month for you.
A monthly tracking sheet to copy
Copy this into a spreadsheet and fill it in on the first Monday of each month. Fifteen minutes is enough.
Month: … Average rating shown on Google: … Rating of the last 3 months’ reviews: … New reviews this month: … Star split: 5★ … / 4★ … / 3★ … / 2★ … / 1★ … Reply rate: … % Unanswered reviews: … Longest reply time this month: … Topics mentioned positively: … Topics mentioned negatively: … Competitor 1 (rating / number of reviews): … Competitor 2 (rating / number of reviews): … Action for the month: …
The last line matters most: one project a month (ask for more reviews, answer old ones, fix a recurring issue), seen through to the end.
Spreadsheet or review software?
| Spreadsheet filled in by hand | Review software connected to your profile | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free | Subscription |
| Time each month | Counting and copying reviews | Numbers always up to date |
| Reply rate, unanswered reviews | Counted review by review | Worked out automatically |
| Acting on the numbers | Reply and ask for reviews elsewhere | Reply and ask for reviews in the same place |
| Best for | Few reviews, one location | Steady reviews, or several locations |
In Voxtya, your account shows how your reviews evolve month by month, your star split, your reply rate (last 30 days and overall) and the list of unanswered reviews. The Review replies service drafts a reply to each one; Review collection helps you get more (QR code, email after the visit, prize wheel). Together they cost €49 a month, or €29 each on their own. Everything is on the page Google review management software.
The steps at a glance
The steps of a monthly Google review check, from reading the numbers to choosing the month’s action.
- Note the rating. The rating shown and the rating of the last 3 months’ reviews.
- Count new reviews. How many this month, and the star split.
- Check your replies. Reply rate, unanswered reviews, longest reply time.
- Read the month’s reviews. Note topics mentioned positively and negatively.
- Look at competitors. Rating and number of reviews for 3 to 5 direct competitors.
- Pick one action. One project for the month, seen through.
Go further
Sources
The rules quoted in this guide come from these official pages, checked on November 9, 2026.